Our harbor ratings are admittedly subjective and intentionally vague. They are meant to help with cruise planning, especially for sailors new to the area. We hope they don't become the cruising equivalent of the racer's PHRF ratings - a disputatious intrusion on cocktail hour.
Massachusetts enjoys a remarkable concentration of fine harbors, most of which come attached to towns over 300 years old. These are the 3-star destinations; in a sense, we recommend them all. You won't get far from civilization, but you won't go wrong.
The harbors we have rated as exceptional, though, are literally set apart. Their character derives more from the water around them than their proximity to commuter rail.
Attractiveness
Scenic, remote, compelling. The best in the area.
A good balance of natural beauty and man-made vitality.
Something to offer, but not to plan your cruise around.
Worth a stop if you're nearby.
Protection
Well protected. Suitable for overnight in anything short of a hurricane.
Good protection for overnight anchorage. Exposed to severe weather from one direction.
Reasonably protected on 2 or 3 sides. An overnight anchorage in mild summer weather.
Protection on 1 or 2 sides. Suitable for lunch in fair weather.
Difficulty
Good chance of a serious grounding without local knowledge.
Tricky in the best conditions, with little margin for error.
Requires prior planning for tide, current or weather. Sometimes impassible, even in routine summer conditions.
Demands increased attention to navigation or boathandling
